Thursday, December 14, 2006

Whose Excellence is it Anyway? - By Christopher Harding

(Article from The CPAF Winter 2006 edition of Transpositions)
Christopher Harding is an assistant professor of Piano at the University of Michigan School of Music, Theatre and Dance.

Let's jump straight into the problem: students, professionals, and even those we call "amateurs" in the performing arts are called to and measured by a standard of excellence. This is even more true for those of us who know God and are called to praise Him publicly ("Sing to Him a new song, play skillfully . . . " Psalm 33:3)

But the definition and application of this standard is unfortunately fraught with a great deal of pain, as all performing artists know. We experience stage fright, we suffer professional jealousy and arrrogance in ourselves (this is indeed true suffering), and often we are choked by our own ambitions to the point of an artistic paralysis that may affect our studies and career, engendering even more fear. And doesn't it seem that these problems are a perpetual treadmill of emotional exhaustion?

What I mean is that our definition of excellence is by nature comparative and exclusionary. As often taught and practiced by the world of business of performing arts, in our education (at all levels) and in our own lives, to be excellent is to be superior to something else. We judge that one performance is more excellent than another, whether it be a comparison of our own performances or someone else's. We seem to see that one talent is bigger or more special than another, and we begin to draw conclusions about the merit of excercising or investing in "lesser" talents. From there, since it is so easy to identify and value one's self with one's talent and accomplishments, it is so easy to begin to make judgements about the worth and quality of ourselves and other people.

Does not the vast majority of the pain we experience in our artistic pursuits proceed from this definition of adherence to excellence, as defined by the world? This pain is etched in the hearts and lives of hundreds and thousands of performing artists, students and "amateurs" who fail to live up to the standard as they perceive it. It is etched in the hearts and lives (an often, the faces) of those who currently define the standard. Is this what God destined us for in blessing us with His gifts? "To be an artist is to live a life of pain, thus producing great art." How many of us have been taught this, believed this, practiced this, loved and worshiped this, experiencing an ever-increasing fear and hardening of heart which we have learned to call "toughness", "experience", or "professionalism"?

Who will rescue us from this body of sin and death? Thanks be to God -- Jesus Christ our Lord! (Rom 7:24-25) Jesus does indeed rescue us, transforming our hearts and minds and renewing our lives as we keep our eyes fixed on Him. He says, "come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you and learn from me, for I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for your souls. For my yoke is easy and my burden is light." (Matt 11:28-30) But what a burden He lays upon us! "Be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect." (Matt 5:48) Isn't this what we are striving for? How is this any easier than what we already practice?

But whose excellence are we committed to? We know (or we think we do) what excellence means in the world- and yet we find that majority of the most excellent performers are not Christians. "No one can serve two masters" (Matt 6:24), and doesn't it seem that to attain the highest levels of performance, we must choose between God and art? Are we not taught to worship our art? Much Romantic and Humanistic thought encourages this, and our performance education and traditions are firmly rooted in that philosophy, but in truth the temptation to sacrifice our lives to excellence in performance must have exsisted since earliest times. Yet we Christians ought to own excellence, since it is God's and we are called to His perfection. What is God's excellence?

We have experienced sustained interaction with godly perfection in the flesh only twice in our collective history: in Eden, before the fall, and in the person of Jesus Christ. The world has been broken since the Fall, but God in his perfect love came to be with us in our brokenness, to save us from it. Jesus ought to be our model of excellence. It is interesting that one of the descriptions of Jesus' excellence (which He acknowledges in a backhanded sort of way) is the word "good:" the rich young ruler in Mark 10:17-22 calls Jesus "Good Teacher," to which Jesus replies, "Why do you call me good? No one is good except God alone." This adjective "good" is parallelled in the Genesis account of Creation, in which God finds all of creation to be good, indeed very good (Genesis 1). Why not just call it perfect, as it was, and be done with it?

Actually, all these words speak to one another of God's excellence in character and work. The Greek word for "good" as used in Mark is agathos, and "describes "that which, being good in its character or constitution, is beneficial in its effect (Vine's Expository Dictionary of Old and New Testament Words)." "Good" in the Genesis account is the Hebrew word towb, connoting the adjectives "beautigul, best, better, bountiful, cheerful, at ease, fair, favorable, fine, glad, good (as in helpful), gracious, joyful, kind, loving, merry, pleasant, pleasing, ready, prosperous, sweet, wealthy, and beneficial to welfare (Strong's Exhaustive Concordance of the Bible)." The word for "perfect" from Matt 5:48 is the Greek word teleios, and "signifies having reached its end (telos), finished, complete, perfect (Vine's Ibid)."

Isn't it striking how very little emphasis there is on comparing these definitions? Instead, there seems to be an incredibly colorful variety of description of something which simply is. We find an awful lot of the fruit of the Spirit (love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self control) in towb. In the case of teleios ("be perfect as your Heavenly Father is perfect"), the emphasis is on completeness, or fullness, after a process of becoming so. In our relationship to God's perfection and excellence, we are in process, and He is. God promises to complete the good work He has begun in us (Phillippians 1:6)-- therefore, each and every one of us who has been gifted by God in the performing arts can look forward to the day of Jesus Christ, where we will be found to be excellent in our art, and in Him. And the excellence will be so in truth and actuality, not just in hope or the striving for the achievement of a standard: we shall be good and perfect, as God now is and has been for eternity. We are made for greatness, becasue we will be like Christ! And does that not include the very gifts we treasure so highly even now?

Of course, this highlights perhaps the fundamental source of pain for us Christians in this broken world: the tension between who we are in Christ and who we find ourselves to be on a daily basis, which is to say, trapped in this body of sin and death. It is painful to be in process, especially when we fail the standards we have defined for ourselves - both in our performance as artists and our performance as Christians. And it is tempting, when seeking to alleviate and assuage the pain of failure, to degrade the standards of God through a misapplication of the grace of god, by calling a performance good which was not good. We feel motivated by all sorts of compassion for a person's feelings, by the desire to encourage, and a myriad of other things. But Jesus never compromised God's standard, and he never failed to apply grace. Consider the beetrayals of Peter, which Jesus foretold and afterwards addressed (John 13:38, 21:15-19). Another example is the woman caught in adultery, who Jesus refused to condemn (John 8:1-11). Jesus called a spade a spade ("leave your life of sin"), et offered forgiveness and freedom, freeing this woman to proceed joyfully along the "path of process" toward godly perfection.

A joyful process toward the fullness (completeness) of perfection: is this not the Godly excellence to which we are called and committed? And it is important to remember that the command "Be perfect, as your heavenly Father is perfect," is couched in a paragraph about love, becasue love is what makes the process possible. In those who do not know God, love for the standard drives the process. For those of us who do know God, however, it is love for Him who is the standard which motivates us and infuses us with joy. For God gave us our gifts for our pleasure just as much as for the edification of his people. He loves to share in them with us, to perform with us, to participate in the process of achieving His perfection with us! Is it too wonderful to realize that God loves art more than we do?

"There is no fear in love. But perfect love drives out fear." (1 John 4:18) This is our gift to the performing arts world, to model God's excellence based on Love for Him. This excellence is good, in all that this word means; and this excellence is a process, fueled by a love for the standard which is the character of God Himself. Soli Deo Gloria!

Tuesday, October 10, 2006

A Musician's Prayer

God, Bless my music that it might glorify your name,
May using it to serve you always be my aim.
Let it be a witness to your majesty and love,
And remind us that you’re watching from your throne above.
May others see your beauty in every note they hear,
And when they hear my music may they feel your presence near.
Oh, Lord, I ask for your guidance in everything I do,
And pray you’ll make my music an instrument for you
.
(Ramona.K.Cecil)